This is a reply to Ryan’s Why I’m a Bad Freetard — Or the Quest for a New Phone.
It’s no secret that I’m an Android Fanboy, I really like the platform, and the idea of an “open” cellphone, but I’m well aware of its flaws.
For starters… Google has yet to ship Honeycomb’s source code, to which I say “What Honeycomb?”.
I’m sticking to CyanogenMod (Gingerbread / 2.3.4) whose code I can recompile (And have recompiled in several occasions), and I won’t migrate to Honeycomb until I can actually build it. Sure, I’m not smart enough to port Android or rebuilt without using a wiki, but I’m also not recompiling my KDE packages or my Kernel and yet I still manage to use my laptop.
And to say that there’s no community of Android enthusiasts is just wrong. There is a real community of both Android users and Android developers.
CyanogenMod is the closest we can get of an “Android Distro”. There’s others, but I’m proud to say that I’ve contributed one thing to CyanogenMod: Trackball Answer.
Sure, my contribution will never be accepted by Upstream (Google), but then again, I also never considered BlueBubble to be accepted by Fedora either, and that’s not stopping me from trying to help others.
And Android also has its fair share of Users. There’s a Facebook-like site dedicated around them, an awesome online store and even its own kind of hat. Hell, a bunch of Android Users got together to have an awesome Barbecue last year (And are planning on repeating it), and even managed to get about 1000 bucks towards a Cancer Research. Sorry, but I’ve never seen Apple fans do any of this.
Yes, Carriers are really screwing over their customers. Yeah, some hardware manufacturers really hate Freedom. Yes, Google is evil and is trying to datamine our every move. Yes, Android doesn’t follow The Open Source Way. Yes, you have to “root” the phone to make it kick-ass.
I’ve seen a lot of people complain about having to “Jailbreak” iPhones or “rooting” Androids to make’em awesome. I had to do the same with my laptop.
It came with Windows 7, and there’s no way I would’ve bought it if I couldn’t replace it with Fedora. And it wasn’t “Stock Windows 7″ either. It came with a lot of annoying crapware, and trialware too, so this isn’t something that’s exclusive to Android.
Would I have rather bought a laptop that came with no Windows? Hell yes I would’ve. But they’re so hard to find, I might as well just pick one I can wipe, and move on. The same logic applies to my phones, tablets, etc. I won’t purchase an Android device that I can’t easily root.
I guess there’s a huge difference between Fedora and Android, and that’s fine. At the end of the day, my cellphone, like my laptop, is just a tool I use to do stuff. And I’ll pick the best damned tool I can get to do it.